Skip to content
The Online
Teacher Awards

How winners are chosen

Judging and Integrity

Every nomination for The Online Teacher Awards is read in full and decided by one named, accountable judge, working to published benchmarks, supported by a structured AI-assisted review and checked by two independent moderators. This page explains how it works, why we chose it, and the rules that keep it fair.

named judge reads every nomination
1
independent moderators
2
equally weighted criteria per category
3
point evidence scale
5

Our approach

Why one judge?

Most awards hand nominations to a panel. We chose not to, and the choice was deliberate. Panels are familiar, but familiarity is not the same as fairness. For an award judged on evidence against published criteria, a single accountable judge, held to clear rules, gives every nominee a better deal.

One standard, from the first nomination to the last

Ask five judges what a score of four out of five means and you will get five slightly different answers. Even experienced assessors score differently, and when entries are divided between them, a nominee’s result can depend on which judge they happened to get. One judge applies one standard to every nomination in every category.

Every nomination read by the person who decides

Large panels usually split the entries, so each judge sees only a share and relies on colleagues for the rest. Here, the person who makes the final decision reads every nomination in full. Nobody is ranked by someone who has not seen the whole field.

The best entry wins, not the safest one

Panels reach decisions by discussion and compromise. That can favour the entry nobody objects to over the one that is truly exceptional, and it leaves room for votes to be traded between categories. A single judge working to published benchmarks has no one to trade with: the strongest evidence wins.

Real accountability

When a panel decides, nobody in particular is responsible for the result. Here, a named judge stands behind every decision, and the reasons for every final score are written down. If a nominee asks why, there is an answer.

Judged by an online teacher

The Founder and Judge, Kizzi Nkwocha, is an online English tutor as well as a publisher and broadcaster. He knows from his own lessons what it takes to teach well through a screen.

The honest trade-off

The honest trade-off, and how we handle it

A single judge brings one risk that a panel spreads out: one person’s blind spots, or one person’s connections. We do not pretend otherwise. That is why every decision is bound by the published benchmarks below, why the judge steps aside wherever there is a conflict of interest, and why two independent moderators review the shortlist and a sample of all other nominations before any result is announced.

Four stages

The Consistent Excellence Framework

Every nomination passes through four stages. AI is not a judge: it is a tool that helps apply the same published standards to every nomination, so that a tutor with five students is measured by exactly the same yardstick as a course creator with five thousand.

  1. Published criteria

    Each of the seven categories has three criteria, and each criterion has published benchmarks describing what weak, solid and exceptional evidence looks like. Nominators can read them before they write a word.

  2. Structured AI-assisted review

    Each nomination is checked against the benchmarks for its category, using the same structured prompts and the same scoring scale. The review suggests a provisional score for each criterion and notes the evidence it relied on. It does not decide anything.

  3. Human assessment and decision

    The Founder and Judge reads every nomination and the provisional review, and sets the final scores. He can and does disagree with the AI. When he changes a provisional score by a full point or more, the reason is written down.

  4. Documented decisions

    Every final score, every change from the provisional score, every conflict of interest declaration and every moderator comment is recorded.

What the AI review does not do.

It does not verify facts, contact referees or judge character. It can favour long, fluent writing over short, plain writing, so the judge assesses evidence, not prose style, and nominations written in a second language are never marked down for language.

Scoring

How nominations are scored

Every criterion is scored on the same five-point scale, and every nomination is scored on all three criteria for its category.

overall score needed for the shortlist
3.5+
minimum on every criterion
3
shortlist places, at most, per category
5
needed for a category winner
4.0

The five-point scale. Select a score

Combining scores

The three criteria carry equal weight. A nomination’s overall score is the average of its three final scores, to one decimal place.

Shortlist

A nomination is eligible with an overall score of 3.5 or more and no criterion below 3. Up to five nominations are shortlisted in each category. If fewer reach the bar, fewer are shortlisted; the bar is never lowered to fill places.

Winner

The winner in each category is the shortlisted nomination with the highest overall score after moderation. If no nomination reaches 4.0, the category may have no winner that year.

Ties

A tie is broken by the higher score on the category’s first criterion, then its second. If nominations are still level, the judge decides after consulting both moderators and records the reason.

Evidence, not length

A short nomination with links to real work, figures and testimonials can score higher than a long one that only describes.

Try it yourself

Would this nomination be shortlisted?

Set a score for each of the three criteria and see the shortlist rule at work: an overall score of 3.5 or more, with no criterion below 3.

First criterion Strong
Second criterion Strong
Third criterion Solid
3.67 average score

Eligible for the shortlist

The white tick on the ring marks the 3.5 shortlist line.

Seven categories

Category benchmarks

Each category guide sets out what a 1, a 3 and a 5 look like for each of its three criteria.

Impartiality

Conflict of interest policy

Because one person makes the final decisions, we hold ourselves to a strict standard of impartiality. These rules are published so that anyone can hold us to them.

Who cannot be nominated

The following are not eligible in any category:

  • members of the Founder and Judge’s family and household;
  • anyone employed or contracted by, or in business with, Kizzi Nkwocha or his companies, including Business Game Changer Magazine and Kizzi Talk;
  • current and former students and coaching clients of Kizzi Nkwocha from the past three years;
  • sponsors, advertisers and paid partners of the awards, and their staff;
  • the independent moderators and their immediate family.

What must be declared

For every nomination, the Founder and Judge declares any relationship with the nominee or nominator: personal, professional, financial, or through social media beyond a casual follow. Each moderator does the same for the entries they review. Declarations are recorded before scoring begins.

What happens next

A declared relationship is tested by one question: could a reasonable person think it might affect the decision?

  • If not, the declaration is recorded and assessment continues.
  • If so, the Founder and Judge steps aside. The nomination is assessed by the two independent moderators, whose average score stands.
  • If neither moderator can assess it impartially either, the nomination is withdrawn and the fee refunded.

Nobody can buy a result.

The nomination fee is the same for everyone and does not affect the outcome. Sponsorship, advertising, media appearances and purchases from any of the founder’s businesses give no advantage, and nominees are never asked to pay to be shortlisted or to receive an award.

Reporting a concern

Anyone who believes a conflict has not been declared can write to us in confidence. Every concern is passed to both moderators, who decide whether a decision needs to be reviewed.

A second, independent check

Independent moderation

Two independent moderators, both experienced educators with no business connection to the awards or its founder, are named on this page each year. Before results are announced they review:

  • every shortlisted nomination and its scores;
  • a random sample of at least one in ten other nominations, to check that the standards were applied consistently;
  • any nomination referred to them under the conflict of interest policy.

Where a moderator disagrees with a final score by a full point or more, the judge and moderators discuss it and the outcome is recorded. Each year the moderators publish a short statement confirming that the process was followed.

independent moderators, named each year
2
every shortlisted nomination and its scores
100%
at least, of all other nominations, sampled at random
1 in 10
or more of disagreement is discussed and recorded
1 point

At least one in ten other nominations is re-checked

The moderators for 2027 will be announced before nominations open on 5 April 2027.

For every nominee

Feedback, honourees and fees

Feedback for every nominee

Every nominee receives their final score on each criterion and a short written comment after the results are announced, whether or not they are shortlisted.

Honourees

The title Honouree is used only for shortlisted nominees and winners. Shortlisted nominees receive a certificate and the Shortlisted digital seal; winners receive a certificate and the Winner digital seal.

US$50

The nomination fee

Each nomination costs US$50, the same for everyone. It pays for assessment, moderation, written feedback and the running of the awards. It does not buy a place on the shortlist. The fee is non-refundable, except when a nomination is withdrawn under the conflict of interest policy.

Results in numbers.

After each year’s awards, we publish the number of nominations received, shortlisted and won in each category, and the number of conflict declarations made and referred to the moderators.

30

days

Process review

Questions about a decision

A nominee who believes the published process was not followed can ask for a review within 30 days of the results. The review checks whether the process was followed; it does not re-score the nomination on its merits. Reviews are carried out by a moderator. Contact us to request one.